Past the 14th Hour: Checking a Truck Driver's Log Against the Federal Rules
A fatigue case often turns on a timestamp the driver's log doesn't show. Here's how to run the hours-of-service math against the carrier's own records, and how to make sure those records still exist when you ask for them.

What are the hours-of-service limits for truck drivers?
Under 49 CFR 395.3, a property-carrying driver may drive 11 hours after 10 consecutive hours off duty, may not drive past the 14th hour after coming on duty, and needs a 30-minute break after 8 cumulative hours of driving. Checking a log against those limits is arithmetic, but the records that prove a violation can lawfully be discarded six months after the carrier receives them.
Three clocks running at once
Every shift runs three daily clocks, and each one measures something different. The 11-hour clock counts driving time only. The 14-hour clock starts when the driver comes on duty and keeps running through fueling, loading and waiting at a dock; a break does not stop it.
The third clock counts driving since the last break. After 8 cumulative hours behind the wheel, the driver needs at least 30 consecutive minutes of not driving. Under FMCSA's 2020 final rule, published June 1, 2020 and in force since September 29, 2020, that break can be any non-driving period, including on-duty time like fueling or unloading.
Weekly limits sit on top of the daily clocks: no driving after 60 on-duty hours in any 7 consecutive days, or 70 in any 8. The window rolls, so older hours drop out of the count day by day, and the driver can also restart it with 34 or more consecutive hours off. A shift can be legal on its own and still fall outside the weekly cap, so pull at least the eight days of logs before the crash.
Where hours-of-service violations hide
Consider a hypothetical shift. The driver comes on duty at 5:00 a.m. after 10 hours off. He drives from 5:30 a.m. to 1:30 p.m., eight hours, then fuels from 1:30 to 2:00, which satisfies the break. He drives from 2:00 to 5:00 p.m., three more hours for 11 in total, and unloads until 7:00 p.m.
At 7:00 p.m. two limits have run out at once. He has no driving time left under the 11-hour rule, and the 14-hour window that opened at 5:00 a.m. has closed. The crash happens at 7:40 p.m. on a highway 40 miles from the delivery address.
The log may show him off duty from 7:00. The proof otherwise sits in the supporting documents, which 49 CFR 395.11 defines to include bills of lading and itineraries, dispatch records, expense receipts, electronic mobile communication records, and payroll records. A fuel receipt, toll record or dispatch message stamped after 7:00 and away from the dock puts the truck in motion when the log says it was parked.
The arithmetic is simple once the documents line up. The hard part is that the log, the receipts and the dispatch messages often arrive in different productions, in different formats, months apart.
The six-month clock on the evidence
The records that prove a violation don't last long. Under 49 CFR 395.8(k)(1), a motor carrier must keep records of duty status and supporting documents for six months from the date of receipt. Driver vehicle inspection reports only have to be kept for three months under 49 CFR 396.11.
Not every receipt has to be kept, either. Under 49 CFR 395.11(d), a carrier generally need not retain more than eight supporting documents per driver for each 24-hour period, and a full day's electronic messages count as one document. When there are more than eight, the carrier must keep the ones with the earliest and latest time indications. That helps in the worked example above: a 7:40 p.m. fuel receipt would likely be the day's latest time indication, which the carrier has to keep. A midday toll receipt has no such protection.
Other files last longer. Inspection, repair and maintenance records must be kept for one year, and for six months after the vehicle leaves the carrier's control, under 49 CFR 396.3(c). The driver qualification file must be kept while the driver works for the carrier and for three years after (49 CFR 391.51); what that file can reveal is covered in How AI Builds Stronger Truck Accident Liability Cases.
A preservation letter sent in week one should name the ELD data, every supporting document the carrier holds (not only the eight it must keep), the inspection reports, the maintenance file and the DQ file. The letter puts the carrier on notice; it can't bring back records already discarded, and whether a later loss counts as spoliation depends on the jurisdiction. A letter sent in month seven may ask for logs the regulations no longer required anyone to keep.
The exceptions the defense will raise
The math above assumes the standard rules apply, and the defense's first move is often to argue they don't. Check each of these against the log and the documents before building a deposition outline around a violation.
Adverse driving conditions. Since 2020, a driver who meets unforeseen conditions such as bad weather or an unexpected road closure may extend both the 11-hour and 14-hour limits by up to two hours (49 CFR 395.1(b)). Ask whether the log claims it and whether the weather record supports it.
Short-haul. A driver who stays within a 150 air-mile radius and is released within 14 hours can keep time records instead of a log (49 CFR 395.1(e)), which changes what you request.
Split sleeper berth. A driver can split the 10-hour off-duty period into one sleeper berth period of at least 7 hours and another of at least 2, and the qualifying periods don't count against the 14-hour window (49 CFR 395.1(g)).
Personal conveyance. FMCSA's 2018 guidance treats personal conveyance as off-duty movement of the truck for personal reasons, and it can't be used to advance a load or stretch the work day. One listed use fits a driver who runs out of hours at a shipper or receiver: driving to a nearby, reasonable, safe place to take the required rest, as long as the trip leaves time for that rest and doesn't pass closer stops on the way to the next load. In the example above, expect the defense to call the 40 miles exactly that; whether it was the nearest safe place, which way the truck was headed, and whether the driver then rested are fact questions.
Pilot programs. FMCSA's Split Duty Period pilot would let enrolled drivers pause the 14-hour window for up to three hours a day, and a Flexible Sleeper Berth pilot would let them split the 10-hour rest with as little as 5 hours in the sleeper berth. FMCSA announced on August 27, 2026 that both had finished pre-tests and are being prepared for expanded launches in 2027, open only to enrolled drivers and carriers. These are controlled studies, not changes to the rules: every driver outside a pilot stays on the standard 14-hour window and the current 7-hour sleeper berth minimum. For crashes in 2027 and later, ask in discovery whether the driver was enrolled.
What the Trucking Negligence Analysis agent checks
A carrier's production in a trucking case can run to thousands of pages of logs, receipts, driver files and maintenance records. The Trucking Negligence Analysis agent in Anytime AI checks that discovery against the federal trucking regulations and the state CDL manual. ⚠ Verify with Hugo
The firm uploads the production and asks Teddy in the case chat. The agent reads the records against the rules and flags possible violations for attorney review, each tied to the regulation and the source document. The state CDL manual adds a second benchmark: what the driver was trained and tested to do in the state that licensed him.
In the worked example, that means the 7:00 p.m. log entry and the later fuel receipt surface together, next to the rules they bear on. Instead of comparing pages across separate productions by hand, the attorney starts from a list of possible violations with the records behind each, and spends review time on the ones that hold up. See the truck accident litigation page for how the agent fits the rest of a trucking file.
Is an FMCSA violation negligence per se?
A violation is not a verdict. Whether a court treats a breach of the hours-of-service rules as negligence per se, as evidence of negligence, or as neither depends on the state and on how the claim is pleaded. Either way, the plaintiff still has to connect the violation to the crash.
That causation link is where the clock math earns its place. A driver past his 14th hour at 7:40 p.m. supports a fatigue argument, and the expert, the reconstruction and the driver's own deposition carry it from the clock to the collision.
What the agent can't tell you
The agent reads only what the carrier produced. A gap in the ELD data shows up as a gap, not an answer, and a fuel receipt nobody preserved can't be flagged. If the preservation letter went out late, the analysis inherits that.
The exceptions above change the math, and some turn on facts outside the documents, like the weather that night or whether a closer truck stop had space. Every flag is a starting point for an attorney's review, not a finding.
Final Thoughts
Pull at least eight days of logs, run the three daily clocks on every shift that touches the crash, and line each log entry up against the receipts and dispatch records. Then test the exceptions before you build a deposition outline around a violation. Of all the rules in this article, the one that matters most in week one is the six-month retention window, because it closes first.
FAQs
How many hours can a truck driver drive in a day?
Up to 11 hours of driving after 10 consecutive hours off duty, with no driving after the 14th hour since coming on duty, under 49 CFR 395.3.
Does a 30-minute break stop the 14-hour clock?
No. The break satisfies the 8-hour driving rule, but the 14-hour window keeps running; only a qualifying sleeper berth period pauses it.
How long does a trucking company keep driver logs?
Six months from the date of receipt for records of duty status and supporting documents, under 49 CFR 395.8(k)(1), so a preservation letter should go out early.
Is an hours-of-service violation negligence per se?
It depends on the state. Some courts treat a breach of the federal trucking rules as negligence per se and others as evidence of negligence, and causation still has to be proven.
Can a truck driver use personal conveyance after running out of hours?
In limited cases. FMCSA's 2018 guidance allows off-duty travel to a nearby, reasonable, safe place to rest, but not bypassing rest stops to get closer to the next load or delivery.
What records should you request in an hours-of-service truck case?
The ELD data and records of duty status, every supporting document (bills of lading, dispatch records, fuel and toll receipts, messages, payroll), inspection reports and maintenance records, focused on the dates the retention rules still cover.
Get Started
Ready to go deeper — and safer?
See how Anytime AI gives plaintiff firms the strategic edge
and the security their clients deserve.